A real pattern our own price history can't verify one way or the other, and why I'm telling you instead of quietly hiding it.
2026-08-24
Half or Nothing
50% off or it doesn't make the page.
2026-08-24 · Written by Checarlos Cruz · 4 min read

Last post I wrote about listings where our tracking couldn't confirm a discount either way, because the price had never moved since we found it. This one is the opposite. These six actually moved, on our own logs, not just on the seller's “original price” label.
For each one below: the peak price we ever recorded, what it costs right now, and the real percentage drop between those two numbers, which is our own measurement, not the seller's claimed discount.
| Item | Peak we recorded | Now | Real drop | Seller's claimed discount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Valentino sunglasses | $315.69 | $183.99 | 41.7% | 79.1% |
| LG 6000 BTU portable AC | $149.00 | $121.00 | 18.8% | 60.3% |
| Bulova men's watch | $244.99 | $200.99 | 18.0% | not disclosed |
| Lattafa Pride Shaheen perfume | $27.35 | $23.42 | 14.4% | not disclosed |
| Eterna Contessa women's watch | $1,860.00 | $1,729.80 | 7.0% | 75.3% |
| CK One cologne | $31.41 | $30.27 | 3.6% | not disclosed |

We first saw this at $181.99, watched it spike to $315.69, then settle at $183.99, where it sits now. That peak-to-now drop is a real 41.7% off, measured across four separate checks. The seller's own listing claims 79.1% off an $880 original price, a number we've never seen this item actually sell at. Our 41.7% is the part we can actually stand behind. Buy on eBay →

$149 the first time we checked, $134 a few days later, $121 now. Three checks, a real step-down each time, no jumps. That's an 18.8% drop we actually watched happen, smaller than the seller's claimed 60.3% off, but every dollar of it is real. Buy on eBay →

Peaked at $244.99 when we first logged it, now $200.99 after a stop at $205.99 in between. Real, gradual movement across three checks, not a one-time reset. Buy on eBay →

This one has the longest history of the six, 22 separate checks since we started watching it. The price crept down slowly, a few cents at a time, from a $27.35 peak to $23.42 today. Not dramatic, but it's the kind of drop you only catch by actually watching something for weeks instead of taking one snapshot. Buy on eBay →

$1,767, then $1,860, then $1,729.80. A real 7% off the peak, nowhere near the seller's claimed 75.3% off a $6,995 original. Buy on eBay →

41 checks logged on this one, drifting from $31.41 down to $30.27. A 3.6% real drop. Buy on eBay →
None of these six real percentages match the discount badge the seller shows. That's expected, their number is against a claimed original price, ours is against the highest price we've personally watched the item hold. Neither number is more “official” than the other. The difference is that we can show you ours happened, check by check, with real dates attached. That's the whole reason this tracking exists.
The real drop is measured from the peak price we've personally recorded for that exact listing down to its current price. The seller's advertised discount is measured against their own claimed original price. Neither is more official, but only one of them we can show happening, check by check.
The Lattafa Pride Shaheen perfume, 22 separate checks, sliding slowly from a $27.35 peak down to $23.42.
Not necessarily. It means the tracked price movement was modest. The item can still clear this site's separate 50% off filter against the seller's own original price, that's a different measurement entirely.
For the full explanation of what this methodology can and can't tell you, see what our price tracking actually proves, and for the general 50% off rule behind every listing on this site, see what counts as a real 50% off.
Every pick we've pulled at 50% off or more, in one place.
Visit our Amazon store ›