The Fall Pieces Worth Keeping: The Quiet Luxury Women's Catalog at Half the Price
Fall's quiet luxury edit for women, dresses, shoes and bags, every piece at 50% off or more, verified live.
2026-09-08
Brand & Category Guides · Half or Nothing
Women's Loafers at 50% Off or More Right Now
Six women's loafers from Cole Haan, Vionic, Sam Edelman and more, each priced at 55 to 72 percent off its listed original price on eBay today, plus more pairs at 50% off or more on Amazon.
- Pieces
- 9
- Checked
- 13 Oct 2026
- Source
- eBay + Amazon
2026-10-13 · 5 min read
Key takeaways
Six women's loafers are live on eBay at 55% to 72% off their listed original prices, and a second list further down covers pairs on Amazon.
The biggest eBay discount is 72% off, and the eBay pairs are ranked from the largest discount down.
Every eBay price below is read from the live listing when this page is built, and any pair that sells out or drops under 50% off is removed automatically.
Every Amazon pair was at least 50% off its list price when we checked it on Amazon on October 15, 2026, and its live price shows inside the card.
Every eBay pair is listed as new. On October 13, 2026 six of the seven sellers accepted returns and one did not, and the line under each pair says which.
Each listing offers several sizes that sell out over time, so check yours on the eBay page before you buy.
A loafer is a laceless slip-on shoe. A penny loafer has a leather strap across the top, and a kiltie loafer adds a fringed flap over the tongue. Both styles wear well from October through spring, and the eBay brands in this list normally sell for well over $150. We pulled the pairs on sale at 50% off or more right now, ranked by discount. If you also shop dress shoes, see our loafer and oxford edit.
The picks
The eBay loafers, ranked by discount
Cole Haan Women's Stassi Kiltie Loafers W33552
$49.99 (was $180.00), 72% off. Sold by rightfootshoes on eBay. View on eBay
Condition on the listing: New with box. The seller accepts returns.
Vionic Women's Cleo Loafer
$49.99 (was $175.00), 71% off. Sold by shoomerangshoomerang on eBay. View on eBay
Condition on the listing: New without box (the seller's own "NW/OB" label). The seller accepts returns.
Sam Edelman Loraine Women's Loafers
$55.00 (was $170.00), 67% off. Sold by leeleetee on eBay. View on eBay
Condition on the listing: New without box (the seller's own "NW/OB" label). The seller accepts returns.
Cole Haan Women's Giana Buckle Loafers Style W30773
$54.99 (was $160.00), 65% off. Sold by rightfootshoes on eBay. View on eBay
Condition on the listing: New with box. The seller accepts returns.
Cole Haan Stassi Chain Loafers Womens Black Flats Casual W27246
$59.97 (was $170.00), 64% off. Sold by official_shoebacca on eBay. View on eBay
Condition on the listing: New with box. The seller accepts returns.
Vionic Women's Caitlin Penny Loafer
$79.99 (was $180.00), 55% off. Sold by shoomerangshoomerang on eBay. View on eBay
Condition on the listing: New with box. The seller accepts returns.
The picks
More women's loafers on Amazon
These pairs are on Amazon at 50% or more off the list price. Each card shows the live Amazon price and has a button that goes straight to the pair on Amazon. Amazon stock is thin on several of these, so a pair can disappear quickly.
WHITE MOUNTAIN Women's Naathan Cushioned Penny Loafer
A penny loafer with a cushioned foam insole and a lightweight build.
Aerosoles Women's Edna Loafer
Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry
A classic Aerosoles loafer in a warm gingerbread brown.
Donald J Pliner Women's Haarlem Loafer
Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry
A Donald J Pliner loafer in a soft sand color.
Vince Women's Sloan Loafer
Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry
A white leather Vince loafer, the priciest pair in this list.
Easy Spirit Women's Aerilyn3 Casual Slip-On Penny Loafer
A slip-on penny loafer you can put on without bending down, offered in extended widths.
As an Amazon Associate, Half or Nothing earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Checklist
Before you buy: a quick fit check
The American Podiatric Medical Association's shoe-buying advice, as reported by HealthDay, is simple. Shop later in the day, when your feet are swollen. Feet are seldom the same size, so buy the size that fits the larger foot. Try on both shoes and walk around, wearing the same type of socks you will wear with them.
Online, that means measuring your larger foot before you open a listing, and choosing the size from the seller's size list rather than from a brand's usual size. If a listing does not accept returns, take that advice even more seriously. The line under each pair says what its seller allows.
The picks
How we checked
Half or Nothing reads eBay listings every hour. For each eBay pair we compare the current price with the original price shown on the listing, and we keep the pair on this page only while it is at least 50% below it. A pair that sells out, ends or falls under 50% comes off the page when it rebuilds. For this post we also read each listing's condition and return policy on October 13, 2026, and those lines are written exactly as the listing states them. The Amazon pairs are different: we check each one by hand on Amazon, and a pair stays on this page only while it is at least 50% below its list price there.
We have not worn or tested these shoes, and the page only describes what each listing says. To see how we judge a discount, read what counts as a real 50 percent off and how to verify a real online deal. Half or Nothing earns a commission from qualifying eBay and Amazon purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Shopping on Amazon for these? Here are some Amazon member perks worth knowing about.
Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you know the discount is real?
For eBay, we compare the current price with the original price on the listing and keep the pair only if it is at least 50% below it. For Amazon, we check each pair by hand against its list price. Listings that end or change are dropped when the page rebuilds.
Can I return these loafers?
When we checked on October 13, 2026, six of the seven listings said the seller accepts returns. One listing, the Donald Pliner pair, said returns are not accepted. Return terms are set by each seller and can change, so confirm them on the eBay page before you buy.
Are all sizes available?
Each listing offers several sizes, but sizes sell out as pairs are bought, so open the pair you like and pick yours on the eBay page.
Every pick we've pulled at 50% off or more, in one place.
Visit our Amazon store ›You might also like
6 Real Women's and Unisex Perfume Dupes at 50% Off or More
Six women's and unisex perfumes live on Half or Nothing at 50% off or more, each compared to a well-known original, plus three dupes for Coco Mademoiselle.
2026-09-29
The Loafer and Oxford Edit: Ferragamo, Bruno Magli, and the Dress Shoes We Found at Half Off
Ferragamo, Bruno Magli, Hugo Boss, Isaia, and Saint Laurent dress shoes at 52-69% off. Real listings, real leather, real half-off prices on Half or Nothing.
2026-09-10